Dispersing agent correction in hydrometer analysis is always
- APositive
- BNegativeCorrect
- CZero
- DCan be either positive or negative
Solution
Concept
Dispersing Agent Correction in Hydrometer Analysis
Formula
R = Rh + Cm - Cd ± Ct, where R is the corrected hydrometer reading, Rh is the observed reading, Cm is the meniscus correction (+), Cd is the dispersing agent/deflocculating agent correction (-), and Ct is the temperature correction (±).
Step-by-step solution
1. Identify the formula for corrected hydrometer reading: R = Rh + Cm - Cd ± Ct. 2. Observe that the dispersing agent correction (Cd) enters the equation with a minus sign (-Cd) to account for increased fluid density. 3. Conclude that the dispersing agent correction is always negative (Option B).
Explanation
When a dispersing agent is added to the soil-water suspension, it increases the density of the liquid. This increased density makes the hydrometer float higher than it normally would, resulting in a higher observed reading than the actual value. Therefore, a negative correction (subtraction) must always be applied to get the correct hydrometer reading.
Shortcut
Remember: Dispersing agent increases fluid density, so the hydrometer reads higher, requiring a subtraction. Shortcut rule: Dispersing = Subtract (Always Negative).
Common mistake
Many students confuse dispersing agent correction with meniscus correction (which is always positive) or temperature correction (which can be either positive or negative), leading them to incorrectly choose "Positive" or "Can be either positive or negative" instead of "Negative".
Correct answer: B) Negative