If in a pin-jointed plane frame m + r > 2j, then the frame is
- AStable and statically determinate
- BStable and statically indeterminateCorrect
- CUnstable
- DStable
Solution
Concept
For a plane truss, Ds = m + r − 2j. If Ds > 0, the truss is statically indeterminate.
Formula
Ds = m + r − 2j
Step-by-step solution
1. The degree of static indeterminacy is Ds = m + r − 2j. 2. Given m + r > 2j, so Ds > 0. 3. There are more unknowns than equilibrium equations. 4. So the frame is stable and statically indeterminate.
Explanation
The unknowns are the member forces (m) plus the reactions (r). Each joint gives 2 equations, so there are 2j equations. When there are more unknowns than equations, the frame is statically indeterminate, and it is taken as stable.
Why the other options are wrong
A: Determinate needs m + r = 2j. C: Unstable is the case when m + r < 2j. D: It is incomplete, because it does not say the frame is indeterminate.
Shortcut
= determinate, > indeterminate, < unstable.
Common mistake
Choosing only 'Stable' and forgetting that the frame is also indeterminate.
Correct answer: B) Stable and statically indeterminate