Select the INCORRECT statement regarding purification of water.
- AScreening is done before plain sedimentation.
- BPlain sedimentation is also known as type-2 settling.Correct
- CSedimentation aided with coagulation is better than plain sedimentation.
- DType-1 settling involves Stoke's law.
Solution
Concept
Plain sedimentation removes discrete particles, so it is Type-1 settling. Type-2 settling is flocculent settling.
Formula
vs = g(G - 1)d2 / (18ν)
Step-by-step solution
1. Screening removes big floating matter. It comes first, before sedimentation, so (A) is correct. 2. Plain sedimentation settles discrete particles without chemicals. This is Type-1 settling, not Type-2. So (B) is wrong. 3. Coagulation forms flocs that settle faster and remove fine and colloidal particles. So (C) is correct. 4. Type-1 settling of discrete particles follows Stokes' law. So (D) is correct. 5. The incorrect statement is (B).
Explanation
In plain sedimentation, particles settle alone, without changing size or shape. This is discrete or Type-1 settling, which follows Stokes' law. Type-2 settling is flocculent settling, as in sedimentation aided with coagulation.
Why the other options are wrong
A: True, screening is the first unit in water treatment. C: True, coagulation removes fine and colloidal particles that plain sedimentation cannot remove. D: True, Stokes' law gives the settling velocity of discrete particles (Type-1).
Shortcut
Type-1 = discrete (plain sedimentation), Type-2 = flocculent (coagulation), Type-3 = zone/hindered, Type-4 = compression.
Common mistake
Mixing up Type-1 (discrete) and Type-2 (flocculent) settling.
Correct answer: B) Plain sedimentation is also known as type-2 settling.