Select the option that is appropriate regarding the following two statements labelled Assertion and Reason. Assertion: The main disadvantage of drip irrigation is requirement for a high initial investment. Reason: Drip irrigation requires regular flushing and supervision.
- ABoth Assertion and Reason are true, but Reason is not the correct explanation of Assertion.Correct
- BAssertion is true, but Reason is false.
- CBoth Assertion and Reason are false.
- DBoth Assertion and Reason are true and Reason is the correct explanation of Assertion.
Solution
Concept
High initial cost is the main drawback of drip irrigation. Clogging of emitters is a separate drawback that needs flushing and supervision.
Step-by-step solution
1. Assertion: Drip irrigation needs pipes, emitters, filters and fertigation units, so its initial cost is high. This is the main disadvantage, so the Assertion is true. 2. Reason: Emitters can clog with silt, salts or algae. So laterals need regular flushing and the system needs supervision. The Reason is true. 3. Check the link: Flushing and supervision are running (maintenance) needs. They do not cause the high initial investment. 4. So both are true, but the Reason is not the correct explanation. Answer A.
Explanation
Drip irrigation is costly to install because of its pipe network, emitters and filters. It also needs regular flushing and supervision because emitters clog easily. These are two different disadvantages, so the Reason does not explain the Assertion.
Why the other options are wrong
B: The Reason is also true, because clogging makes flushing and supervision necessary. C: Both statements are true, not false. D: Maintenance needs do not explain the high initial (capital) cost.
Shortcut
Initial cost is capital cost, while flushing is maintenance. Different causes means option A.
Common mistake
Choosing D just because both statements are drip irrigation disadvantages, without checking the cause-effect link.
Correct answer: A) Both Assertion and Reason are true, but Reason is not the correct explanation of Assertion.