Which of the following combinations is most critical for achieving both high flow ability and segregation resistance in Self-Compacting Concrete (SCC)?
- ALow water-cement ratio with no superplasticizer
- BHigh superplasticizer dosage with low powder content
- COptimal superplasticizer dosage combined with high powder contentCorrect
- DHigh coarse aggregate content with low viscosity modifying agent
Solution
Concept
Flowability and segregation resistance requirements in SCC
Formula
NONE
Step-by-step solution
1. Self-compacting concrete (SCC) must flow into formwork without mechanical consolidation while maintaining a cohesive matrix. 2. High dosages of superplasticizers (polycarboxylates) disperse cement grains, providing high deformability and flowability. 3. High powder content (materials < 0.125 mm) increases plastic viscosity and cohesive strength, preventing aggregate segregation. 4. Therefore, an optimal superplasticizer dosage combined with high powder content is the critical combination. Answer: C
Explanation
Self-compacting concrete (SCC) requires high deformability to flow under its own weight and high cohesion to prevent segregation and bleeding during flow. An optimal dosage of polycarboxylate superplasticizer achieves high deformability, while a high powder content (cement, fly ash, silica fume, or limestone powder) provides the necessary plastic viscosity and stability.
Why the other options are wrong
A) Low w/c ratio without superplasticizer produces an unworkable stiff mix that cannot self-compact. B) High superplasticizer with low powder content causes severe aggregate segregation and bleeding. D) High coarse aggregate increases particle interlocking and causes blockage across reinforcement.
Shortcut
SCC requires high flowability (superplasticizer) + high segregation resistance (powder content).
Common mistake
Assuming superplasticizer alone creates SCC, forgetting that high powder content is vital to prevent segregation and bleeding.
Correct answer: C) Optimal superplasticizer dosage combined with high powder content