Which of the following systems is most sensitive to hydraulic shock loading affecting biomass retention?
- ASequencing Batch Reactor
- BTrickling Filter
- CUpflow Anaerobic Sludge BlanketCorrect
- DPrimary Clarifier
Solution
Concept
Hydraulic sensitivity and biomass retention in UASB reactors
Formula
Upflow velocity vup < Settling velocity vs of sludge granules
Step-by-step solution
1. In UASB, biomass is retained purely by gravity settling of anaerobic granules against upward flow. 2. In trickling filters, biomass is attached to fixed media and cannot wash out easily. 3. SBR operates in batch cycles where settling is decoupled from flow surges. 4. A hydraulic surge in UASB creates excessive upflow velocity, washing the unattached sludge blanket out of the reactor. Answer: C
Explanation
An Upflow Anaerobic Sludge Blanket (UASB) reactor relies on self-immobilized anaerobic granular sludge that remains suspended as a blanket by balancing upward liquid velocity and gravity settling. A sudden hydraulic shock load increases upward velocity beyond the critical settling velocity of sludge granules, causing massive biomass washout and system upset.
Why the other options are wrong
A) SBR is a batch process with discrete fill and react steps that absorb hydraulic shocks easily. B) Trickling filters have attached biofilm resistant to biomass washout. D) Primary clarifiers do not retain active biological biomass.
Shortcut
UASB = Granular sludge blanket suspended by velocity balance; hydraulic shocks cause washout.
Common mistake
Selecting Trickling Filter, overlooking that attached-growth biofilms are very resilient to hydraulic shock.
Correct answer: C) Upflow Anaerobic Sludge Blanket