A 3 × 3 group pile having pile diameter of 500 mm passes through a 10 m thick saturated clay layer. The length of each pile is 9 m and c/c spacing is 0.25 m. Constrained modulus for the stress increase range is 10,000 kPa. If the magnitude of primary consolidation settlement of the pile group is 0.4 m, then the working load applied on the pile group is
- A6000 kN
- B9000 kNCorrect
- C5000 kN
- D4000 kN
Solution
Concept
Consolidation Settlement of Pile Groups
Formula
Primary consolidation settlement: S = (Δσ × H) / M, where S is settlement, Δσ is stress increase, H is clay layer thickness, and M is constrained modulus. Distributed load area: A = (B + z)², where B is the width of the pile group and z is the depth below the equivalent raft foundation level. Working load: Q = Δσ × A
Step-by-step solution
1. Find remaining clay thickness below equivalent raft at 2/3 pile length: H = 10 - 6 = 4 m. 2. Calculate stress increase using Δσ = (S × M) / H = (0.4 × 10,000) / 4 = 1000 kPa. 3. Calculate effective area at mid-depth (z = 2 m): B = 2(0.25) + 0.5 = 1.0 m, A = (1.0 + 2)² = 9 m². 4. Calculate working load: Q = Δσ × A = 1000 × 9 = 9000 kN.
Explanation
The correct working load is 9000 kN. For a pile group, the load is assumed to act at 2/3 of the pile length (6 m deep), leaving 4 m of clay below it.1. Calculate average stress increase: Stress Increase = (Settlement × Constrained Modulus) / Clay Thickness \= (0.4 m × 10,000 kPa) / 4 m = 1000 kPa 2. Calculate effective area at the middle of the layer (2 m below load depth): Width of group B = 2 × spacing + diameter = 2(0.25 m) + 0.5 m = 1.0 m Distributed Area = (B + z)² = (1.0 m + 2 m)² = 9 m² 3. Calculate working load: Load = Stress × Area = 1000 kPa × 9 m² = 9000 kN
Shortcut
For pile group consolidation in clay, remember the 2/3 length rule for equivalent raft depth and 2:1 stress dispersion. Use Δσ = (S × M) / Hclay to quickly find stress increase, then multiply by effective area A = (B + z)² to get working load Q = Δσ × A.
Common mistake
A common mistake is using the full length of the clay layer (10 m) or the full pile length (9 m) instead of the remaining clay thickness below the equivalent raft level at 2/3 depth (4 m) when calculating the stress increase and consolidation settlement.
Correct answer: B) 9000 kN