In a group of piles, the "Group Efficiency" is usually less than 1.0 for
- APiles in loose sand
- BPiles in dense sand
- CPiles in plastic clayCorrect
- DPiles driven to rock
Solution
Concept
Pile group efficiency in plastic cohesive clays
Formula
ηg = Qug / (n × Qup) < 1.0
Step-by-step solution
1. Pile group efficiency is the ratio of group capacity to the sum of individual single pile capacities: ηg = Qug / (n × Qup). 2. In plastic cohesive clays, installing a closely spaced pile cluster remolds the clay and causes extensive overlap of shear stress zones. 3. Block failure of the soil mass often controls over individual perimeter friction, resulting in ηg < 1.0 (typically 0.7 to 0.85). 4. In loose sand, compaction from driving increases relative density, making ηg > 1.0. Answer: C
Explanation
In cohesive plastic clays, driving or boring a pile group causes stress zone overlaps and remolding of the sensitive clay matrix. As a result, the group capacity is lower than the sum of the individual pile capacities, leading to a pile group efficiency (ηg) of less than 1.0 (100%).
Why the other options are wrong
A) Driven piles in loose sand compact the surrounding granular soil, yielding ηg > 1.0. B) Piles in dense sand maintain efficiencies near or above 1.0. D) End-bearing piles on rock transfer load directly to bedrock without stress overlap reduction.
Shortcut
Piles in loose sand: ηg > 1.0 (compaction); Piles in plastic clay: ηg < 1.0 (stress overlap).
Common mistake
Believing group efficiency is less than 1.0 in loose sand where pile driving actually densifies the deposit.
Correct answer: C) Piles in plastic clay