What is the main difference between PERT and CPM?
- APERT deals with probabilistic time estimates, while CPM deals with deterministic time estimatesCorrect
- BPERT is used for repetitive projects, whereas CPM is used for research projects
- CPERT is cost-oriented, while CPM is time-oriented
- DCPM uses three-time estimates for each activity, while PERT uses only one
Solution
Concept
Comparison between PERT and CPM network techniques.
Step-by-step solution
1. Understand the core nature of PERT: It deals with probabilistic time estimates (three-time estimates: to, tm, tp) and is used for non-repetitive or R&D projects. 2. Understand the core nature of CPM: It deals with deterministic time estimates (single time estimate) and is used for repetitive construction projects. 3. Match these definitions with the given options to find that option (A) is correct.
Explanation
PERT (Program Evaluation and Review Technique) is event-oriented and uses probabilistic time estimates (Optimistic, Most Likely, Pessimistic) to handle uncertainty in R&D projects. CPM (Critical Path Method) is activity-oriented and uses deterministic time estimates, making it suitable for repetitive construction projects where activity durations are well-known.
Why the other options are wrong
B: PERT is used for research projects, whereas CPM is used for repetitive projects. C: CPM is typically considered more cost-oriented (crash cost optimization), while PERT focuses primarily on time/schedule uncertainty. D: CPM uses a single time estimate, while PERT uses three time estimates.
Shortcut
PERT = Probabilistic, R&D, Event-oriented; CPM = Deterministic, Construction, Activity-oriented.
Common mistake
Confusing the time estimates and project types between PERT and CPM (e.g., thinking PERT is for repetitive projects).
Correct answer: A) PERT deals with probabilistic time estimates, while CPM deals with deterministic time estimates