Which of the following clay minerals has the highest cation exchange capacity?
- AKaolinite
- BSmectiteCorrect
- CIllite
- DChlorite
Solution
Concept
Cation Exchange Capacity of Clay Minerals
Formula
No
Step-by-step solution
Since this is a theoretical question, no mathematical steps are required.1. Identify the key concept: Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC) depends on the specific surface area and expanding crystal structure of clay minerals. 2. Compare the given clay minerals: Smectite (Montmorillonite) has a 2:1 expanding lattice with high surface area, giving it the highest CEC compared to Kaolinite, Illite, and Chlorite. 3. Select the correct option: (b) Smectite.
Explanation
Smectite has a 2:1 expanding crystal structure with weak interlayer bonds, which allows water and exchangeable cations to easily enter between its layers. This structure creates a very high surface area and significant negative charge due to isomorphic substitution, giving smectite the highest cation exchange capacity among the choices.
Shortcut
Remember the keyword "S" in Smectite: - Smectite = Supreme / Super high Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC) and Swelling.Order of CEC (Highest to Lowest): - Smectite >llite > Kaolinite (Remember the sequence: S-I-K)
Common mistake
Many students confuse Kaolinite with Smectite due to Kaolinite being frequently discussed in basic soil mechanics, or they incorrectly mix up the order of cation exchange capacity between Smectite and Illite.
Correct answer: B) Smectite